Unscented shaving soap

[Miyagisan]

Has anyone tried the Simpsons Fragrance-Free Luxury Shaving Soap? I am looking for a new unscented soap and I am stuck between Stirlings, Simpsons, Henri et Victoria. Since I am on a budget, these 3 are in my price range that I can afford.

Any suggestions?

 

[willk93]

Never tried Simpsons soap, but out of those three, go with Stirling Unscented with Beeswax

 

[NorthernSoul]

Haslinger Sensitive 60g pucks are $6.99 each at Pasteur Pharmacy in NYC. This is a fragrance-free, long lasting, vegetable based hard soap with very good performance, made in Austria. Free shipping with orders over $35 if you need anything else shaving related they probably carry it.

Remember, soft soaps have a high water content. You are paying for water, plus they don't last as long as harder soaps do.

 

[Miyagisan]

Haslinger Sensitive 60g pucks are $6.99 each at Pasteur Pharmacy in NYC. This is a fragrance-free, long lasting, vegetable based hard soap with very good performance, made in Austria. Free shipping with orders over $35 if you need anything else shaving related they probably carry it.

Remember, soft soaps have a high water content. You are paying for water, plus they don't last as long as harder soaps do.

I’m from Canada so it’s gonna cost me a fortune

 

[Miyagisan]

Never tried Simpsons soap, but out of those three, go with Stirling Unscented with Beeswax

What about Stirling Sheep?

 

[willk93]

What about Stirling Sheep?

The mutton tallow base is an excellent performer and some here have argued it’s even better than their already great beef tallow base. I’m just not a fan of the “gamey” scent it has. The beeswax soap is truly scentless

 

[BrianP]

While it's a little more cost up front, Canada Shave Soap is a great performer and good value for money. It's gonna take a loooong time to get through that tub. I don't have any experience with the unscented varieties of the other three brands you mentioned, so I can't offer a comparison.

 

[BoSox15]

What about Stirling Sheep?

This is my go-to unscented soap. Honestly, it's my go to, period. There is no scent when you're done shaving so it goes with any aftershave/cologne you choose to use.

I can't say it's better or worse than the other ones you've mentioned because I haven't tried them. And at the end of the day these are all subjective opinions, but for the price point give it a try!

 

[bartje-p]

What about Stirling Sheep?

I have 2: Naked & Smooth and the Sheep. Sheep outperforms the N&S, which is already a great soap. The N&S is actually unscented. The sheep has a sheepish (wool) smell, which you will get used to and diminishes over time. I think the Sheep has the best skincare of all soaps I have tried so far, even better than my MdC soaps (Including the unscented Nature).

 

[thombrogan]

@Miyagisan , if you’re shopping Top of the Chain, Stirling Unscented With Beeswax or Pedro Fiasco Unscented are probably great starting points. Of them, I’ve only tried Stirling’s unscented offerings and of those, their Unscented With Beeswax would make a great first choice (if not destination) because it doesn’t have lanolin.