Top 5 Soaps

[bobskins]

#4 is my best

there's always a plan B.

 

[1Vader]

B&M
Haslinger
Stirling
Arko
Cella

 

[ClintonP]

Soap Commander
Captain's Choice
Stirling
B&M
Taconic

 

[GreggJ]

For me its.

MDC
MWF
Tabac
I Colonali
Mikes Hungarian Lavender

In the summer I would sub Stirling MITA for Tabac.

 

[DEdestroyer77]

In no particular order

Stirling (Executive Man, Piacenza, Barbershop)
Czech & Speake 88
Pre de Provence 63
Haslinger Schafmilch
Penhaligon's

Very honorable mention: Chiseled Face, Sudsy Soapery, Stone Cottage

 

[mightyeskimo]

Tabac
Razorock The Dead Sea
Uncle John's Rise & Shine
Soap Commander Lime
D.R. Harris Windsor

 

[LabGuy]

Granted, I have only tried 5 different soaps. So here are my favorites in order:

Haslinger
Stirling
B&M
Cella
Arko

 

[shoelessjoe]

Tabula Rasa
PannaCrema Nuàvia
B&M
Saponificio Varesino
Razo-Rock

 

[Graybeard57]

I had three vendors, but QCS closed shop. I'm down to two vendors:

Mike's Natural Soaps
Cold River Soapworks

 

[ask4Edge]

D.R. Harris (Almond, Arlington, Windsor)
Tabac
I Coloniali with Mango oil
AoS tallow
GFT tallow

 

[stook2001]

Someone earlier in the thread had posted the aggregated counts for all the votes. I tallied them again. This was perhaps not a perfect effort but it should be pretty close to accurate. There were a couple of people that posted that they had only tried a few soaps and so I left those out from the tally (sorry). Hopefully this is helpful for someone.

Tabac 38
Mitchell's Wool Fat 25
Stirling 25
Haslinger 23
Barrister & Mann 18
Martin de Candre 18
Arko 16
Cold River Soap Works 15
Razo-Rock 15
Mike's Natural 12
Saponificio Varesino 12
DR Harris 11
Pre de Provence 11
Cella 10
I Coloniali 9
Soap Commander 9
Proraso 8
TOBS 8
Valobra 8
caties bubbles 7
PannaCrema Nuàvia 7
La Toja 6
AOS tallow 5
chiseled face 5
paa 5
Sudsy Soapery 5
Antica Barbeira Colla 4
Captain's Choice 4
Fine Accoutrements 4
Palmolive 4
Czech & Speake 3
Henri et Victoria 3
la shaving 3
le pere lucien 3
l'occitane 3
Reef Point 3
Speick 3
WSP 3
Dapper Dragon 2
Derby 2
dr. jons 2
Klar Seifen 2
L&L Grooming 2
LEA 2
Maggard 2
Mystic Waters 2
phoenix and beau 2
trumper 2
Williams 2
Black ship grooming 1
Boots 1
BWW 1
Calani 1
Camelot 1
colonel conk 1
deluxe 1
dr. dittmar 1
Elvado 1
erasmic 1
First Canadian 1
gft 1
Master 1
Meissner Tremonia 1
Mickey Lee 1
Midnight & two 1
Monsavon 1
Mystic Water 1
Pannacrema Pure2O 1
Penhaligon's 1
Ppa 1
Provence Sante 1
Queen Charlotte 1
Route 66 1
Salus Bay Rum 1
Santa Maria del Fiore Sapone da Barba Shaving Soap 1
Soapy bathman 1
St Charles Neroli 1
stone cottage 1
Tabula Rasa 1
Taconic 1
tallow & Steel 1
tbs 1
Tcheon Fung Sing 1
the fat 1
topanga 1
truefitt & hill 1
Uncle John's 1
viking soap 1
XPEC 1
zartgefuhl rasierseife ziegenbart 1

 

[cjarvelo]

MdC
D.R. Harris
LPL
Tabac
Klar

 

[OregonGunDog]

Phoenix Artisan Accountrements
Czech & Speake
Tabac
Barrister & Mann
Fine

 

[Doug57]

D. R. Harris Arlington
Tabac
MWF
AOS Lavender (Tallow)
Haslinger Schafmilch

 

[Raven Koenes]

Tabac
Stirling
Haslinger
Proraso
Valobra

Not in any particular order.

 

[joeyboy]

Looks like cost may be affecting the tally with less expensive toward the top and more toward the bottom.

 

[ZigZiglar]

Looks like cost may be affecting the tally with less expensive toward the top and more toward the bottom.

Yep. Perceived value.

 

[joeyboy]

Yep. Perceived value.

Agree

 

[deckie007]

Haslinger Aloe
Haslinger Sheepy
La Toja
RazoRock Mudder Focker
Soap Commander Courage


Sent from my SM-G920W8 using Tapatalk

 

[shave/brush]

Tabac
Mystic Water
MWF
La Toja
Arko