The TOBs cream is great stuff, especially the peppermint. I find the soap to be OK, but not in the same league as DR Harris. It takes more work to lather than Harris, it's not as slick, and the post-shave feel not as good.
Maybe they've reforumlated it but all three TOBS pucks I've used lathered and performed every bit as good as DR Harris, in fact the sandalwood puck I'm using produced as good if not a better lather then what I usually get from DR. Harris and MWF soaps.