Was never able to try the Valobra version. I have some bath soap made with real Mysore sandalwood oil and the Aos sandalwood doesn’t smell anything like that. The AoS is way too synthetic smelling to as are most sandalwood products I’ve triedMany years ago I had a puck of the old formula Valobra made soap. It lathered up a storm of course but I never liked the scent. It was nothing like real sandalwood BTW, maybe more of a patchouli/cypress/weird thing going on.