What's new

Super iridum vs Polsilver

Thanks to Xillion and sorry for the long wait on the review. I couldn't find the original PIF thread so I started my own. Xillion was kind enough to send out a few sets of Super Iridium and PolSilver Super Iridium Blades for some lucky members to try out.

I planned to load the blades 4 times each in a 1940s Gillette Superspeed and my preshave routine the same each time with each blade and the results were as follows. I have extremely ingrown hair prone skin, not too sensitive just easily get infected hairs, so take this review with a grain of salt. Each shave is WTG one pass with some touchups every other day to let my facial hair recover.

The first blade up was the Super Iridium, I loaded it with no expectations but was pleasantly surprised. It was a bit tuggy at first but overall a nice close shave. By the third shave the blade really was a smooth, nice clean shaver, no weepers. I made it through the 4 shaves and was happy, had a few slight ingrown hair bumps but nothing out of the ordinary. Overall a nice smooth shaver, no really tugging after the first shave and left a nice smooth face. I could see myself buying a few of these blades.

The second blade up was the PolSilver SI, I also loaded it with no expectations but was left wanting a different blade. The first shave was noticeably not smooth, pulling and just not a great shave. I went one more round with the blade and had to trash it, the second shave was worse than the first, over the next few days I began to have the worst ingrown hair episode since I switched from cartridges almost a year ago. I may have gotten a dud blade but the Polsilver SI was definitely not for me.

As with all shaving products YMMV and again thanks to Xillion for letting me try out the blades!
 
Last edited:
Are you talking about the new package polsilver super iridiums or the discontinued polsilvers?

I have a bunch of the discontinued pol silvers and there one of the best blades I have used. Perfect smoothness and very sharp.
 
Totally agree with your assessment, jgriest. SIs are magical. But the Polsilver originals (not the new Pol SIs) have been a huge disappointment.
 
I haven't tried any Super Iridiums (#1 below) yet or the Polsilver SIs (#2) but the discontinued Polsilvers (#4) have been great. They're magical in a 2011 R41.

Here's a thread comparing all four blades.

attachment.php


It looks like xillion sent out an SI and a Polsilver SI to members to compare. You should probably refer to them as SIs and Polsilver SIs. Just saying Polsilver makes me think of a different blade altogether (#4).

Here's a picture from xillion's PIF thread showing that he sent out SIs and Polsilver SIs.

proxy.php
 
Last edited:
I haven't tried any Super Iridiums (#1 below) yet or the Polsilver SIs (#2) but the discontinued Polsilvers (#4) have been great. They're magical in a 2011 R41.

Here's a thread comparing all four blades.



It looks like xillion sent out an SI and a Polsilver SI to members to compare. You should probably refer to them as SIs and Polsilver SIs. Just saying Polsilver makes me think of a different blade altogether.

Here's a picture from xillion's PIF thread showing that he sent out SIs and Polsilver SIs, no Polsilvers were sent out.

Thanks for clarifying with pics because the whole discussion can get lost if the descriptions are wrong. :thumbup1:


So the difference between #3 Polsilver & #4 Polsilver is that #3 was the original Made in Poland type while #4 were Russian, correct??

Anyone ever shave with the original Wizamet Polsilvers (#3 in pic) ?
 
Last edited:
I haven't tried any Super Iridiums (#1 below) yet or the Polsilver SIs (#2) but the discontinued Polsilvers (#4) have been great. They're magical in a 2011 R41.

Here's a thread comparing all four blades.

attachment.php


It looks like xillion sent out an SI and a Polsilver SI to members to compare. You should probably refer to them as SIs and Polsilver SIs. Just saying Polsilver makes me think of a different blade altogether.

Here's a picture from xillion's PIF thread showing that he sent out SIs and Polsilver SIs, no Polsilvers were sent out.

proxy.php

Thanks for the headsup, I edited the post refer to them as Polsilver SI's but couldn't edit the title. I received from Xillion #1 and #2 in the first picture above.
 
Thanks for the headsup, I edited the post refer to them as Polsilver SI's but couldn't edit the title. I received from Xillion #1 and #2 in the first picture above.

No worries. I just wanted everyone else to be clear what kind of blades you were comparing.
 
I have 310 blades of the original polsilver wizamet made in poland blades. blade #4 in pic above.

Only on the box (of 250 blades) has made in lodz poland. No "made in" on each individual box of 10 blades

blades been sitting for around 2 months since my new fav is now the gillette silver blue besides the iridium super

how much can 300 of the original polsilver fetch now?
 
Top Bottom