Saint Charles Shave New Spice or Queen Charlotte Soaps Old Spice?

[Kentb]

Saint Charles Shave New Spice or Queen Charlotte Soaps Old Spice? Which is better? Easier on the skin? Smells more like OS? Who has tried these and can provide a review? Mama Bear's burns my face and I want something that smells somewhat like OS.

 

[Deacon Frank]

I've only tried the QCS, but it's a great product. Smells just like the OS cologne once it has been applied to the skin.

 

[RatMan]

I have had Saint Charles new spice and love it, It wasn't till recently that I even knew what OS smelled like. But now that I think about it it did smell a lot like OS. anyway You can't go wrong with New Spice, plus you get free samples of soap that last quite a while. I say go for New Spice.

 

[SmoovD]

I have never used Matt's Old Spice but I would imagine that it is his take on Old Spice. SCS New Spice scent is nothing at all like Old Spice. Both soapers are excellent BTW.

 

[shaverjoe]

I have used the QCS OS soap and it is simply wonderful.

 

[rickboone1]

New Spice is a great scent. I wouldn't really compare it to Old Spice, but more to awesome.

 

[chron67]

I don't see an old spice type on QCS site

 

[mretzloff]

We no longer make Old Spice Type as a shaving product, so I think that kind of narrows down your choices for you

 

[chron67]

We no longer make Old Spice Type as a shaving product, so I think that kind of narrows down your choices for you

Care to elaborate why?

After using your GIT type soap I believe you have killed my soap acquisition disorder. Everything else I use seems inferior. Guess that still leaves your other scents as options heh.

 

[kingfisher]

New Spice smells sweet like caramel. Or candy. Or caramel candy.

Not like Old Spice.

I think Krissy at Prairie Creations still makes an Old Spice scented soap.

 

[Kentb]

My tin of Saint Charles Shave New Spice arrived yesterday and I shaved with it this morning. Amazing lather! You are correct. It does not smell like OS. To me it smells like vanilla waffer cookies, but I like that!

 

[SmoovD]

My tin of Saint Charles Shave New Spice arrived yesterday and I shaved with it this morning. Amazing lather! Youent aside are correct. It does not smell like OS. To me it smells like vanilla waffer cookies, but I like that!

Scent aside, isn't the lather outstanding. Love SCS soaps.

 

[Kentb]

Scent aside, isn't the lather outstanding. Love SCS soaps.

Absolutely. They also sent me a sample of something called "Woods." I'll try that tomorrow morn.