Trumpers is a little spend-yer, but both are solid performers. Trumpers Coconut and Taylors St. James are my favorites from each brand and are excellent creams.
Trumpers Pros:
Lathers well.
Has Lavender and Rose scented creams.
Cons
Scents not as strong as you'd expect for a cream this price.
TOBS Pros:
Lathers well.
Has Uniquely manly scents (Mr. Taylors, Shave Shop, way more "British" than Trumpers)
Cons:
Lathers well, not as plush as Trumpers maybe.