I never tried any of these. The Orange Amber sounds interesting. Who makes it and who sells it?
Which is why I own Lavender, Classic, Orange Amber, Spiced Citrus, Lime Basil and NOT Oakmoss...I will not be swayed! (secret, they were out when I ordered the lot)...ENABLERS...Well, not so fast there bucko. In addition to the Classic, you absolutely MUST buy the Oak Moss and Orange Amber. And you thought this hobby would save you money. Not with us enablers here to make sure you don't. Hehehe.
It is not like Bay Rum as far as my nose tells me. Subtle and a very muted Italian citrus like blend. Great performer like the rest of their stuff. I have some old stock and a new one that I am going to open to compare once done, I will let you know if the new stuff is more of a Bay Rum scent...I've only tried the Classic, Oak Moss and Orange Amber. I might consider trying Spiced Citrus but if it smells anything like Bay Rum, I may pass. I'm not a huge Bay Rum fan as far as creams go, although I do use it during the winter as an aftershave.