As a pilot, I tend to steer towards aftershaves over colognes as company policy is fairly strict on strong scents. So begins an aftershave that is along the lines of the Musgo Real Oak Moss shave cream which I really enjoy.
Musgo Real Oak Moss No.1 aftershave/cologne. It’s subtle and pairs with the same shave cream. Surprised you haven’t paired them. They offer it on their website as a set.