La Toja
MWF
Cade (could easily be DR Harris Arlington)
I left the unobtainium off the list (AOS tallow and Old Spice), and Tabac, because the scent would keep it from being a daily soap (small doses for this great latherer).
Williams Mug Soap
TOBS (Mr Taylors, Eton College)
Barrister & Mann (so far, I've only tried Seville, but I love the scent enough to put it on my list)
Honourable mention: Proraso Red
Many of my favourites have a habit of disappearing.
- First Canadian's "Barbershop Taper Fade" - now is a cream instead of soap, and name changed to "Barbershop"
- Nivea 's Moisturizing Shaving Cream seems to be disappearing from the shelves
- Crabtree & Evelyn's "Sienna" cream - discontinued 5-10 years ago.
Close 4th is MMcN but I just can't quite fit it in the top 3 if for no other reason than I think their scents are almost all not quite "there" for me....only exceptions are Mandate of Heaven and Ouroboros.