I couldn't wait to get this, it smells like a lime lollipop at the very beginning, then it turns to some soap smell that reminds me of the soap my mom used to stick in my mouth when I was a kid! (yup, I had colorful vocabulary)...
I have the Clubman in my rotation and like it very much, but I have to agree that the Lime Sec does not appeal to me at all. I do not care for the Citrus Musk as well.
It does have that "candy lime" smell, similar to Godrej Lime shave cream.
I'm more of a fan of the genuine lime citrus scent as you would find in the Lime Old Spice, so I sympathize with your take on it.