No matching aftershave for El Caballero. Suggestions?

[Hugo Drax]

I just bought the El Caballero soap from Oleo. Matching aftershave was unavailable. Any suggestions on alternates?

 

[jesseix]

It looks like Maggard has the AS in stock... but in taking a quick look at the scent notes you might also try:
Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber (probably a little more leathery)
MacDuff's Prairie Rum Runner (probably a little more rum-y).