Looking for recommendation: Simpsons Commodore X3 vs Muhle silvertip

[DiNaN]

Hello forum!

After having used a relatively cheap badger brush for some month now i decided to buy myself a better one.
Since i do not really have experience with shaving brushes i read a lot of posts (the field seems to be endless)
and am now undecided between the Simpsons Commodore X3 and the Muhle silvertip (L) brushes.

I would be happy to get any recommendations, experiences or suggestions on which brush to buy.

Thanks,
DiNaN

 

[Vivasanti]

I have a Muhle silvertip, its very soft and luxurious, it feels floppy compared to my TGN 2 band but its definately a tad softer, hope this helps

I also love the handle on it, very pleasant on the eye and comfortable to hold.

 

[Legionensis]

I find Mühle silvertip too floppy but it is very pleasant to use. On the other hand, the Commodore 3 can be used for bowl and facelathering and is also soft-tipped while retaining enough backbone.
If you are upgrading from a cheap badger and want to treat yourself to a quality brush, I would lean towards the Simpson. It is more "substancial", so to speak, and will be a great change from your current gear.

 

[beardybrewer]

Muhle =
Simpsons =


Big boobs or practical, dependable girl next door? Both can be fun!

 

[TheLegalRazor]

I have the x3 and am very pleased with it. Soft but with enough backbone, it seems to do everything well.

 

[Loric]

Do you bowl or face lather? Soaps or creams?

Of the two I would go with the Simpson. I have a Muhle knot I custom set at a low loft and its a nice brush. However at the stock loft, I find them to be way to floppy to for my tastes. As for the Simpson, its a nice middle of the road brush, good for most gear and techniques.

 

[DiNaN]

I'm still trying out what's the best for me. But most of the times (if i have enough time) i use a bowl.
Sometimes i use cream but mostly soaps.

If I'm understanding right, the Simpson is a more versatile brush? At the moment im tending to buy the X3.


And thanks to all the replies so far!

 

[Loric]

If I'm understanding right, the Simpson is a more versatile brush? At the moment im tending to buy the X3.

And thanks to all the replies so far!

Exactly, and your welcome

 

[sgtd]

View attachment 272409

Mother of God...

 

[StylinLA]

Mother of God...

No doubt a beautiful woman, but that face is so Photoshopped her mom would recognize her.

 

[andrestole]

I got 2 mühle silvertips and im waiting for an commodore x2. I really like the mühle, but cant wait to get the simpson. The logical thing to do is buying both i think. you will eventually..

 

[DiNaN]

Well yes, youre probably right. At some point I will buy the other one. But at the moment i want to spend money on only one brush.

 

[andrestole]

well i get mine in a few days, if you can wait i can compare the 2 and say what i think?

 

[sgtd]

No doubt a beautiful woman, but that face is so Photoshopped her mom would recognize her.

She had a face?!?!

 

[DiNaN]

well i get mine in a few days, if you can wait i can compare the 2 and say what i think?

Sure, would be very appreciated.

€: Umm somehow i quoted the wrong post. I wanted to quote yours, andrestole.

 

[andrestole]

FYI my 2 mühles are a classic silvertip and a stylo.

 

[CHSeifert]

No doubt a beautiful woman, but that face is so Photoshopped her mom would recognize her.

It is photoshopped - but she looks really great with no photoshopping, which I think you see in this pciture:



Elsa Benitez - model

 

[DiNaN]

So I've got my Commodore now for some time and it is simply amazing!



The difference to my old brush is so astonishing ... I only now know whats meant by "backbone" of a brush.
I don't even want to use my beginners brush anymore.
Now I only need a second nice (but not so expensive) brush to rotate with.