Institut Karite vs AOS SS, some thoughts

[rickshah]

Hi Folks,

I wanted to do a comparison/contrast between two soaps that I personally think highly of, in case anybody is interested.

Cost
IK is cheaper ($15/100 gram puck vs $26/95 gram puck) but AOS is generally easier to find locally, thus eliminating the shipping cost for some.

Scent
AOS has the edge here, largely as a result of having more options, but this is not the category where either brand really shines. IK has an understated soapy scent that is pretty forgettable. AOS comes in three scents- I have a puck in a fairly muted lavender, but I have heard that the sandalwood is stronger.

Efficiency
I think this is where IK really shines. AOS creates thick, rich lather that provides a smooth and comfortable shave with little effort. IK does the same thing, but with added moisturizing properties that consistently improve the overall condition of my skin. This is a rare trait in my experiences, and something that I prize above other things.

Both great products, but for what it's worth I keep going back to the IK.

 

[Crixus]

AOS SS has tallow, while IK does not. That's a big difference for tallow-averse shavers.

 

[azmark]

IK has shea though. IK is an excellent soap and very moisturizing and is as good as AoS in shaving results IMO. I love both soaps and really like the IK fragrance and I think this is where IK may lose some voters.

 

[oversaturn]

AoS soaps are actually made by Valobra.
The component's list of this soaps is almost identical to the Valobra shaving stick.

Never tried AoS soaps, since they are not available here in Portugal. But my bride bought me a couple of Valobra shaving sticks while in Italy (among other related items). Still haven't tried them yet.
And I have IK soap, which is one of my favourite soaps.