In order, I would say 1805, Grafton, then Sandalwood.
My father, who also wet-shaves would arrange it as Grafton, Sandalwood, then 1805.
Our respective wives would arrange their picks as: Sandalwood, Sandalwood, then whatever. There is some sort of feminine conspiracy going on here from what I can tell.
As I remember, Rose & Grafton were the only two I would consider purchasing. I think I also liked Ultimate Comfort & Trafalgar, but I need to sample those two again. The rest of the scents I did not like at all.
I liked the Grafton and the 1805. They stuck out the most in my mind. I haven't tried the Ultimate Comfort or the Trafalgar yet, ut read good things about them. I thought the others performed well also.
The first one i've tried so far is the 1805, and it is very nice / clean smelling. It's a bit faint compared to the very powerful TOBS Sandalwood I was previously using. I'm interested in trying the Grafton and comparing it to the 1805. Perhaps I'll have to get a sampler...