It ran out. After just a few uses, the Honest Amish is quite pleasing. Scent is faint but noticeable which can often be a good thing right under your nose. It does not take as much priduct as the Aphrodisiac did. Beard seems softer. Plus you can get it locally here.I do not have a favorite at the moment. I used some samples from Bad Azz Beard Care I think its called. I really liked them all and they had several scents that were very pleasing to me. Get the trial kit, comes with oils and balms. I am currently using Grave Before Shave Aphrodisiac. It is not bad, but I probably prefer the Bad AZZ Beard Care. It is relatively price, but it goes a long way. You really do not need much. I plan to try Honest Amish next. Just waiting on Aphrodisiac to run out.