It look me a while but I finally found my #1 go to beard oil, it's by Artius Man - Midnight Ride, it's a little thicker but lasts all day, scent is Black Licorice (Sambuca), so if you like this smell, it's what you need! I can apply it at 6am and at 8pm while in the gym can pick up little hints of it. They also sell samples if you don't want to commit to a full bottle.
For beard Balm, I like Grave before Shave - Bay Rum scent, it's a medium hold but the scent stays with you all day on a mild side.
I also picked up a Scotch Porter set (Shampoo, Conditioner, Balm and Serum) as they are having a 50% off holiday sale but the scent I picked......I'm not happy with, although my son likes it so he is using it now.