I own 2 45's and one of them the clutch cap was in terrible shape till I dug it out with needle nose and replaced the piece. The other one had nib problems that I had to order a replacement for. Now both pens work fine. It takes me forever to go through ink though and I have three inked at the moment that I like better. Maybe next time.I usually stick to having 3 fountain pens inked, but brought a 4th pen into play last night. After seeing a Parker 45 for sale, I inked up the one I have, to remind myself what I like and don't like about it. Diamine Majestic Purple was used.
The ergonomics are fantastic. Such a smooth writer too, and the nib assembly is great for maintenance. That clutch cap still really puts me about though. If it had a positive click, I'd almost certainly buy more, but as it stands my Parker IMs will remain my most frequent users, and the 45 will just be occasional use.
I own 2 45's and one of them the clutch cap was in terrible shape till I dug it out with needle nose and replaced the piece. The other one had nib problems that I had to order a replacement for. Now both pens work fine. It takes me forever to go through ink though and I have three inked at the moment that I like better. Maybe next time.
The clutch cap has worn the section on mine a little, which doesn't help matters. I still prefer a nice satisfying click when the cap seats, to let me know it is home safe.
View attachment 1853700
I do like the ergonomics of the long section though. The only other pens I have with a long smooth section are two Ohto Tasche (shown below it). The Tasche do have a positive cap retention, and although the section is a little slender, I trust it more than the 45.
As for my other pens, they all have fairly similar (to each other) ergonomics, which I am quite happy with.
View attachment 1853699
From the top:
Baoer 388 (Modelled after the Sonnet, I think. I use one and have several spares)
Parker IM (I currently have 4, and use them all)
Parker Jotter (I only have this one)
Helix Oxford (I use 3, plus have a spare)
All metal bodies. All trustable caps. The ergonomics fit my hand well for the most part, though the Jotter is a little too slender for extended writing. It's fine for contrast work with red ink though. These, to me, are what a pen should feel like in hand.
So I decided not to nab that other 45 Flighter. For day to day writing, I am much happier with the pens in the second pic, for the reasons shared. I do like using the Tasche pens occasionally too, but it's not too long before I drift back to the Baoer, Helix, and IM. Occasionally, very occasionally, I will ink up this cheap Wing Sung demonstrator, which is the only threaded section pen I have handled, which I can use for more than a line or two without the threads infuriating me.
View attachment 1853705
Again, it's never long before I return to the "safety" of my metal bodied pens, and I don't risk using the demonstrators if I know I'm having a bad brain day (more clumsy than normal).
I have admired your IM’s but I would like to handle one first,
I think I have scratched my Vintage itch. 6 out of 11 have been leaky on delivery, add to that my Parker 45 woes for 2 more. Of those I haven't over spent, and, expected it. My only two modern pens are both Lamy 2000's. So far the only other pens that have interested me are the Hero 600 series Parker 51 knockoffs that come in multi-packs. For 7 dollars it seems like a safe chance. The IM's seem sturdy and relatively attractive. As far as penmanship goes, if I can keep in the lines I am happy. I was more interested in the vintage filling systems than anything else.Don't stray too far out of your way to get one if you like vintage pens. They're not an enthusiasts pen. Snap on cap, smallish nib, heavier laquered brass barrel and cap, hard as nails nib, Chinese made, and a rather unassuming and utilitarian profile.
For me, that's exactly what I want from a pen. Comfortable, functional, affordable, reliable. Whack some ink in, and it just works. I'm not someone who wants line variation, or shading, etc. However, for anyone who likes those things, or who calls handwriting "penmanship" the IM could quite easily be a soulless disappointment.