Captain's Choice Bay Rum soap and Ogallala Bay Run aftershave. While I love CC Bay Rum and CO9T aftershaves, sometimes I just need a 1950s clove fix that I only get from Ogallala a/s. I love the clove in Ogallala a/s, the shave soap not so much. I don't find the shave soap to be great, but I sometimes use it as a shower soap.