Ok girls and boys. Which do u prefer?
Vs
- Thread starter Burnside
- Start date
MdC - good stuff!
It's a no-brainer for me. MdC hands down.
I haven't tried the newly reformulated SMN, so I'll have no problem voting for MdC.
MdC
MdC is the best soap I have used bar none.
MdC all the way.
I prefer soaps without menthol to soaps that have it. Performance to me is the same. I enjoy the scent of lavender. MdC it is.
Ben
Ben
MdC. Simply superior.
MdC.
If I could only use one soap or cream for the rest of my days (Heaven forbid), it would be Scented MdC.
Santa Maria Novella Lavenda AS is a favorite.
Santa Maria Novella Lavenda AS is a favorite.
Last edited:
OldSaw
The wife's investment
I have to ask. Of those who voted, how many have actually used both?
I would have thought the results would be closer to 50/50 in a group of people that have used both. However, since MDC has been a popular topic I can't help but think that this has influenced popular opinion.
I have only recently been given a sample of MDC and unfortunately my Santa Maria Novella is all gone, so I couldn't do a side by side analysis. However, I think the two products are both very good, extremely good even. The scents are different, but the end result of the shave, comfort and feel are both on the highest level.
I would have thought the results would be closer to 50/50 in a group of people that have used both. However, since MDC has been a popular topic I can't help but think that this has influenced popular opinion.
I have only recently been given a sample of MDC and unfortunately my Santa Maria Novella is all gone, so I couldn't do a side by side analysis. However, I think the two products are both very good, extremely good even. The scents are different, but the end result of the shave, comfort and feel are both on the highest level.
OldSaw
The wife's investment
That stuff rocks.
OldSaw
The wife's investment
It's been reformulated? Crap! Not sure I want to buy another one now.
- Thread starter
- #15
Im thinking about getting one or the other. Havent tried either. Wanted to know opinions on the two
Antique Hoosier
“Aircooled”
Just got my MdC. Fantastic soap. Best non-tallow soap I have ever used.
Have never used SMN
I will withhold my vote as I've only tried MdC, but if you think SMN is in the same league then I guess I have a new soap to add to my wish list. Oy!
I'm not going to vote. I have only tired a sample of MdC. But now I have another soap to try...
OldSaw
The wife's investment
After using MdC today, I've definitely decided, I prefer SMN. It's a close race but there it is.
Similar threads
