What's new

The ULTIMATE Belgium Yellow Coticule/Blue Whetstone NATURAL COMBO STONE!!!!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was fortunate enough to come upon what I consider one of the rarest, best honing stones in existence...and I am now the humble owner. It's a genuine Belgium Yellow Coticule and Blue Whetstones from the Ardennes in Belgium; it was cut from where the two veins met, where the highest density of garnet crystals occur. This stone is quite old, but you can not tell by looking at it. There are no foreign inclusions whatsoever on either side; it's half yellow, and half blue with a distinctive blurry line where the two stones meet. This is important to make note of because there are a lot of false "combo" stones out there where a yellow is simply glued to a blue. This is the genuine article; the appraiser said the yellow side has a garnet percentage of upwards of 70% and the blue side 50%. This is unheard of with traditional blues and yellows of today, and for the majority of those mined over the years. The stone is absolutely gorgeous and hones like no other stone I've ever used before in my life
$bybc8.jpg$bybc3.jpg$bybc4.jpg

The wet-spots on the stone are from my fingers; it's very glossy, which I was told means that it is as close to perfect as possible. It's by far the best Belgium coticule I've come across in a very long time. It's such a beautiful stone that I don't want to hone on it! I've never actually seen a stone from the meeting of the veins until I purchased this one. Let me know what you think...
 

Attachments

  • $bybc2.jpg
    $bybc2.jpg
    19.6 KB · Views: 497
  • $bybc5.jpg
    $bybc5.jpg
    18 KB · Views: 495
Here's one of mine, 250mm x 60mm. La Petite Blanche, which is nearly always a combo

View attachment 256865
View attachment 256864

I had the opportunity to buy a similar stone; a combo yellow-blue, but it wasn't cut from the natural vein. It was much bigger, but it wasn't of the same quality as the one I purchased. It was very common practice to glue Blue's to the back of Yellow's, especially as they became more scarce to increase the rigidity of the Yellow Coticule. I was very fortunate to find the stone I did, and was lucky the guy was willing to part with it. He didn't really know what he had; though I explained the rarity of it to him, he still decided to sell it to me. He actually wanted more for the bigger one that was glued together and had foreign inclusions in it. Nice guy, but not well versed in honing stones..
 
I had the opportunity to buy a similar stone; a combo yellow-blue, but it wasn't cut from the natural vein. It was much bigger, but it wasn't of the same quality as the one I purchased. It was very common practice to glue Blue's to the back of Yellow's, especially as they became more scarce to increase the rigidity of the Yellow Coticule. I was very fortunate to find the stone I did, and was lucky the guy was willing to part with it. He didn't really know what he had; though I explained the rarity of it to him, he still decided to sell it to me. He actually wanted more for the bigger one that was glued together and had foreign inclusions in it. Nice guy, but not well versed in honing stones..

This site might be of interest to you. Lots of good information there.
 
Thanks for the info; I'm actually acquainted with the Hasedic Jewish family that has the mining rites to the last quarry in the Ardennes. The quarry is inundated with water, and the pumps aren't powerful enough for efficient mining. They are focusing currently on sandblasting to just acquire garnet crystals; it's very rarely that they stop to mine BBW. Only when they come upon Yellow Coticule do they take care to mine it with care. But the offerings have been so erratic, and the overall quality and thickness poor that it's not worth it to them. That's why I find that vintage coticules are the way to go. I feel like I found the holy grail of coticules with the stone that I procured. I sent pictures of it to my friend in Belgium, and he was amazed my the purity of it. He himself has never seen such a clean, glossy coticule. He said it was reminiscent of the stones the Romans would praise to sharpen their swords centuries ago. I knew it was rare, but not to the extent that this guy is telling me. Thanks for the link!
 
Sorry to be the one to break this to you but this is a common type of brick used in Belgium, in fact I've just finished an extension on the back of my house using just this type! Send it to me and I'll incorporate it in the back wall and send you a picture afterwards!


Lovely stone, beautiful nuances, happy honing!
 
Sorry to be the one to break this to you but this is a common type of brick used in Belgium, in fact I've just finished an extension on the back of my house using just this type! Send it to me and I'll incorporate it in the back wall and send you a picture afterwards!


Lovely stone, beautiful nuances, happy honing!

Unless your building the most expensive alter to worship honing stones, than you are blatantly messing with me...

If I had enough of these stones to build anything, I'd sell them piecemeal and retire!
 
Unless your building the most expensive alter to worship honing stones, than you are blatantly messing with me...

If I had enough of these stones to build anything, I'd sell them piecemeal and retire!

Hey, not only do we have beer and chocolate and waffles in Belgium but we have coticules-a-plenty. I was digging my allotment this weekend and unearthed a good half dozen, whats even more incredible is that they come out of the ground ready lapped!

Just pulling your leg.

Still, if you ever get fed up looking at it or honing on it then PIF it to me! :001_tt2:
 

Legion

OTF jewel hunter
Staff member
Nice natural combo. I have a couple, though I don't really use the blue side. This is my main workhorse stone.

proxy.php
 
Nice stone. Did you just buy this off eBay? That looks to me to be a newly mined stone of the La Grise variety. And I'm pretty certain that coticules don't have that high of a garnet percentage.
 
Last edited:
Congrats on the stone (wouldn't mind having it myself!), but something sounds fishy to me...like someone put a bunch of over-hype behind the sale of it to you. I'm sure it works great, but please don't get too caught up in all the "best" this and "ultimate" that. There are tons of types of honing stones, and different people swear by different things as being the best. For that rock itself, for example, some would claim it would be better from a diff't vein, or longer rock, or wider/skinnier.

No doubt a beautiful rock, though, just not as rare as you seem to have been told.

Now, on to learn how to use it well! ;)
 
Last edited:
Nice stone. I love mine.
 

Attachments

  • $Photo Mar 07, 8 49 05 PM.jpg
    $Photo Mar 07, 8 49 05 PM.jpg
    37.1 KB · Views: 363
  • $Photo Mar 03, 10 39 46 PM.jpg
    $Photo Mar 03, 10 39 46 PM.jpg
    31.3 KB · Views: 365
  • $Photo Mar 07, 8 49 45 PM.jpg
    $Photo Mar 07, 8 49 45 PM.jpg
    34.8 KB · Views: 362
That sure is a nice stone, but like others said, they are not that rare...
Hope you didn't pay to much for it.

Newly mined or vintage doesn't really mean anything. Since they have been in the ground for more then 480.000.000 years, 100 years back & forth really don't matter much.

Enjoy it!
 
I am more curious how did that that appraiser guy figure out the garnet % in the yellow and the BBW sides of the stone?
 
I was very fortunate to find the stone I did, and was lucky the guy was willing to part with it. He didn't really know what he had; though I explained the rarity of it to him, he still decided to sell it to me. He actually wanted more for the bigger one that was glued together and had foreign inclusions in it. Nice guy, but not well versed in honing stones..

That's a lie. You bought this stone off eBay. I was watching the it and was amazed at how much some one would pay for a 4x2.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom