Very generous PIF, well done! Please don't include me in the list but Mama Bear is my favorite and there is no way I could pick a favorite I haven't even tried them all yet.
I gotta go with C.O. Bigelow.
As I am still new and have been pretty much using that exclusively with an occasional foray into something different. But always get a good shave with it.
Very Generous PIF please include me.
No outstanding favorites for me so far. Right now I'm in rotation with Speick, Arko and Cella. I haven't tried any of the products in the PIF with the exception of the T&H Lavender. Great PIF!
Coconut Lime is my favorite, but just got a soap from The Shave Den called "Monkey Farts" can't go wrong with that! Makes me laugh just typing the name! Great PIF, count me in!