I simply don't care about the scent of an aftershave (as long as its not unpleasant). For me, all I care about is how it affects my skin.
I am wearing Grafton cologne at the moment. I can confirm that it lasts at least 12hrs, and lingers for up 48. The same is true for Truefitt 1805. Can't comment on the AS.
It might be worth getting the cologne then......