Soaps that I'm quite happy with

[BlueTomorrow]

I haven't tried the Palmolive but each of the other four i'd be content to use all the time. The two Prorasos represent 100% of the soaps i currently own, i have a tub of another brand of cream to round things out.
dave

Palmolive is an excellent, no-frills, low-cost soap. It's a shame that it isn't sold here in the USA. In my experience, it performs very well in both hard and soft water. I also really like the blue Wilkinson Sword stick, though the Wilkie is a little more costly for basically the same performance with a slightly more enjoyable scent (though both smell fine).

 

[Bogeyman]

Palmolive is an excellent, no-frills, low-cost soap. It's a shame that it isn't sold here in the USA...

There are online USA vendors who sell the Palmolive stick.

 

[BlueTomorrow]

There are online USA vendors who sell the Palmolive stick.

Right you are! I meant it's a shame that it isn't sold in stores like it is (was?) in some countries in Europe.

 

[fastyouth1313]

My favorite soap, that’s seems to last forever is the sandalwood TOBS! I also love me some cella!

 

[dmshaver]

Soaps I'm very happy with:

Top of my list is CBL Premium Soaps: Outlaw, Norse Spice, & Fresh Vetiver are my favorites.

Next on my list is Mikes Natural Soaps: Barbershop, & Orange/Black Pepper/Cedarwood

Others that certainly deserve consideration are PdP, Haslinger, & MWF

 

[fendy1]

My favorite soap, that’s seems to last forever is the sandalwood TOBS! I also love me some cella!

+1 for TOBS Sandalwood - a very creamy high quality soap

 

[bmw45mo]

As of now, my favorites are as follows:

Noble Otter = The Noir Et Vanille, Flying Hide, Lonestar
Crown & Crane = Cognac & Cubans, Tobacco Leaf & Amber
Murphy & McNeil = Trinity, Mandate of Heaven
Phoenix and Beau = Spitfire, Whitechapel
Stirling = Executive Man, Island Man

 

[kingfisher]

Soapy Science in any scent. This is my top performer.

I also enjoy:

MW
RR WTP
Stirling
Mike's
CRSW

 

[steveclarkus]

Tabac
MWF
Haslinger Schafmilch
Arko

 

[imcnok]

Here is my list:

• MdC fougere and agrumes
• MWF
• Mike's orange cedar pepper
• Haslingers (Schafmilch and Coconut)
• Cold river citrus
• D.R. Harris (windsor)
• Alvarez gomez cream
• Czech & Speake

 

[AimlessWanderer]

Mitchell's Wool Fat
Palmolive Classic

I'm beginning to wonder why bother with anything else.

Haslinger Schafmilch is a good MWF substitute, if your water doesn't want to play nice with the real thing.

 

[njpaddy]

My 5 favorite soaps:
Harris Almond (out of 5 DRH I've had)
Captain's Choice North (bay rum my #2 CC)
Stirling MITA (out of 15-20 I've tried)
SRD Opus X (discontinued, so used sparingly)
SRD West Indies Bay (discontinued, so used sparingly)

 

[TheGrimWeeper]

Great thread idea...

• Stirling Barbershop and Sandpiper
• La Toja stick
• Arko
  
• Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber and Sherlock
• Captain's Choice North (R.I.P.)
  
• MWF
• Williams

 

[seattleshaver]

I just use Stirling now. My favorites are Nag Champa, Ozark Mountain, Sandalwood and the seasonal offering...Christmas Eve.

 

[1Vader]

Tallow & Steel v2 base.
Declaration Grooming bison base.
WK Buffalo base.
B&M Excelsior base.
Sudsy Soapery non-tallow base.
Grooming Dept. I am starting to appreciate this brand, if only they weren't always sold out, I would try more bases and scents. Hopefully the availability also improves in time.

 

[Tallships]

Cella (kilo)
Arko stick(pressed into bowl)
Williams/Dove
Other soaps I liked: VDH,Col. Conk, Proraso, Mama Bear

 

[RhoCurly]

Stirling Eucalyptus Mint is my absolute favorite, followed by
Stirling Ozark, Arko, and VDH Glycerine

 

[pbrmhl]

I’ve got many I enjoy but, over time, MdC and the legacy Declaration bison base have risen to the top in my den.

 

[Darkknight79]

Taylor of Old Street.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Russrat]

It’s B&M Reserve week. It’s just a fabulous soap.