Ultimately, the size you prefer will be based on individual factors and preferences. That being said, I will note there is a difference within the Chubby line between the two-band and three-band versions. I have owned all three Chubby sizes in both two-band and three-band versions. Generally, the three-band versions have a denser knot with softer tips that bloom more. The two-band versions have a less dense knot, in comparison to their respective three-band counterparts, less bloom and soft tips, but not quite as soft as the three-band. Having used all, my personal preference is for the two-band varieties. I currently have five two-band Simpsons in my rotations -- Chubbby 1, Chubby 2, Chubby 3, Tulip 3 and Polo 8. Of the Chubbies, my personal preference is for the Chubby 1 or Chubby 2. The Chubby 1 handle is somewhat small in the hand, but the brush works incredibly well, especially for face-lathering soaps. The Chubby 2 is more substantial in the hand, and also an excellent performer.
Last edited: