Have not tried the Azur Lime. I liked the scent of the Red, but my wife's unusually strong negative reaction put an end to that one on the first try. Soaps and creams seem to be reproducing in my cabinet. Every time I open it, there is a growing stack. Guess I need to join the 3017 club and declare a moratorium - or maybe not.I’m a big fan of Proraso evergreen, but I can see why it’s not for everyone. I wasn’t a fan of the Red and the Blue has a black liquorice scent I couldn’t un-smell. Have you tried the Azur Lime? Very good.