Shaving brothers, a while back I asked about Pinaud Eau de Quinine hair tonic and whether or not it could be used as an AS. I did buy some, and wanted to share how much I like it. Those who recommended it were right. As others said, it does have a slight cherry pipe tobacco kind of scent, maybe some mild powdery kind of vibe as well - really pleasant and smooth. Not greasy or oily at all, so it works well as an AS for me. The only downside is that it has a red color that could get on your clothes (similar to Aqua Velva's blue dye, it seems). I have not found that it was a problem once it had a moment to dry, but do be careful with that.