this is somthing i've been thinking about trying as it's quite a cheap cut of meat. i've seen recipes where you use a dutch oven but as ive only got a weber grill...
We've only used it in oxtail soup. Mmmmmm! The bigger pieces comer from closer to the bum have the most flavour!
BBQing it first beforehand sounds like something I'll try come summer.
You usually need to cook it using low heat until it falls off the bone which sort of cuts out grilling which is a fast high heat cooking style
Get a decent bottle of red wine. Cut up some aromatics (onion, celery, bell pepper, garlic) and cook them in 3-4 tbl of olive oil until the onions are clear. Then add about 1/4 of the bottle of wine and let the alcohol steep off, then add the ox tails. Add 1-2 cups of stock (veal is best but if you haven't made stock recently use a can of unsalted chicken stock). Pour in a 2 1/2 size can of diced tomatoes or a pound of fresh Roma (pealed and diced). Season with salt, pepper, basil, a couple of bay leaves (and any other favorite herb). Turn the burner down as low as it will go, put a lid on the pan, and walk away for 2-3 hours. Serve it with rice.
I'd smoke it, braise it in beer until tender, then grill it. It's not something I've tried before but I've cooked with oxtail quite a lot and it needs VERY long cooking times. There's no reason why you couldn't smoke it or grill it up, but it will need that slow braise in liquid
I love ox tails but I never see them whole. I make stew with them. I see them for around $10 for a small package, not cheap in my book. I can get a chuck roast the size of a toilet seat for the same price!
Any hoo! Check out this link for grilled pig tails. I think the same technique would work for ox tails?
I've smoked and then braised a number of those tough cuts, including oxtails and tongue. Smoke them low for a few hours, and then braise or stew them for a few more (or so--"until it's done!"). You can use a crock pot, or go with a covered roasting pan in a low (210-225F) oven.
I'd hesitate to cook oxtails completely on the pit, as I don't want to lose so much of the good stuff to the bottom of the pit!
I am not sure I care about smoking oxtails. Oxtails are great and flavorful already. But tongue for sure. Wasn't tongue frequently smoked as a standard deli thing anyway? Tongue is an underrated meat to me.