Open vs Closed combs
- Thread starter BigTex_21
- Start date
The benefit for me is a better shave with open combs. And SE open combs the best of all. But your technique has to be up for it
Kind of like stiffer skis, great if your skiing is up to it, otherwise stick to the soft ones. Won't perform as well in theory but may perform better for a given person.
Can't go wrong buying a shaving grade NEW or Old Style and working with it for a few months. Angle and pressure, angle and (no) pressure.
Kind of like stiffer skis, great if your skiing is up to it, otherwise stick to the soft ones. Won't perform as well in theory but may perform better for a given person.
Can't go wrong buying a shaving grade NEW or Old Style and working with it for a few months. Angle and pressure, angle and (no) pressure.
The main benefit that I can think of. Teeth marks from the open comb if your angle is off. The lather is picked up by the blade not the safety bar like a closed comb.
Other than that, different open comb are different models of DE only. Like closed comb, there are mild and aggressive open combs...
Other than that, different open comb are different models of DE only. Like closed comb, there are mild and aggressive open combs...
- Thread starter
- #4
Yes, but then, if you don't like one, you might like another one... It's like changing a Superspeed blue tip for a Superspeed red tip. Similar but not the same.
Try a Gillette NEW to start with and give an Old Type a chance...
this is a slightly tangential observation, but the use of the term "closed comb" cracks me up. Once you close it up, it's not a comb anymore, right?
It becomes a safety bar.
I guess it's kind of awkward to say "open comb versus safety bar," though.
Oh, well. Carry on.
It becomes a safety bar. I guess it's kind of awkward to say "open comb versus safety bar," though.
Oh, well. Carry on.
I first tried an open comb razor more than a year after I switched to wet shaving. I find the Gillette New and New Improved razors to give me as close a shave as anything I've ever tried and I use them frequently. As mentioned earlier, the open comb razors really help you improve your technique. When you have the correct blade angle, you don't get a trail of teeth marks. After using my open comb razors for several weeks, I found that my shaves with a Superspeed, Rocket or Diplomat were all much better. I would encourage anyone to try one of the New or New Improved Gillettes; both for the great shaves they provide and the immediate feedback they provide regarding good shaving technique.
this is a slightly tangential observation, but the use of the term "closed comb" cracks me up. Once you close it up, it's not a comb anymore, right?
I guess it's kind of awkward to say "open comb versus safety bar," though.
Oh, well. Carry on.
There does seem to be a closed comb, if one really want to be specific, which is not synonymous with "safety bar". An example would be the type of guard found on a Gem 1912, as classified by Robert K. Waits. What he refers to as a "modified comb" I've also called a closed comb, but I'll defer to his authority. So, it's quite possible the OP did, in fact, not mean "open comb versus safety bar". All this does get pretty pedantic for some of us, though.
Last edited:
Definitely try another if the first one does not work for you.. I have a Gillette Old Type and New Type. I can't stand shaving with the Old type but my wife and daughter love it for their legs and I find the New type shaves quite nicely.
- Thread starter
- #10
