This is a discussion that originated in the "short story reading group" and as it is off topic for the purposes of discussing the short story by H.G. Wells "The Red Room", I thought a separate thread was in order.
I consider myself to be a rational, intelligent individual. I do not believe in ghosts, hobgoblins, witches or the other supernatural nonsense that some folks do believe in to even some minor extent.
I have had a few instances of what is in the Philippines is called "Bangungot" (Bahng-oong-oot).
When one sleeps, the brain turns the body off during dreams, so that one doesn't sleep walk, or thrash about and injure themselves.
In Bangungot, one begins to wake up, but the body, for some reason does not wake up at the same time. What you have in that case is an odd waking period where you slowly become aware of no longer sleeping, that you can see the room about you, but you cannot move.
For whatever reason, as has been documented with some brain function electromagnetic experiments, the mind becomes aware that there is some "entity" near you. It may be as mild as just feeling like someone is there, it may be more pronounced and your mind interprets shadows or objects in the room as the thing that is there with you, or you may even feel as though you are being touched in some way, perhaps because the body begins very initial return to wakefulness state.
Now, I can tell you - though I am a rational, non-superstitious man - that waking up, being paralyzed, having the sense that something is near you, and then feeling that something put its arm around you induces fear.
It is a non-rational fear. It is an unlimited and uncontrolled fear. It is primeval and ingrained in us.
In each case, I was able to, with effort, begin to vocalize. Eventually sufficiently enough that my wife wakes up, and shakes me, and gets my body to get back into sync with my brain.
Immediately I am back to normal. I have no problem going right back to sleep, and I realize the scientific phenomenon that has occurred.
But... I can tell you that the fear for those seconds is the most terrifying thing you can possibly imagine.
The condition has been studied and is associated with Sudden arrhythmic death syndrome, where individuals have died in their sleep.
In the three times in my life that it has happened to me, if the fear had for some reason gone on for a longer period - I can understand how one might die from cardiac arrest.
I explain this because the story we read makes me think of that raging, uncontrollable, visceral fear and how the young man in the story felt.
I consider myself to be a rational, intelligent individual. I do not believe in ghosts, hobgoblins, witches or the other supernatural nonsense that some folks do believe in to even some minor extent.
I have had a few instances of what is in the Philippines is called "Bangungot" (Bahng-oong-oot).
When one sleeps, the brain turns the body off during dreams, so that one doesn't sleep walk, or thrash about and injure themselves.
In Bangungot, one begins to wake up, but the body, for some reason does not wake up at the same time. What you have in that case is an odd waking period where you slowly become aware of no longer sleeping, that you can see the room about you, but you cannot move.
For whatever reason, as has been documented with some brain function electromagnetic experiments, the mind becomes aware that there is some "entity" near you. It may be as mild as just feeling like someone is there, it may be more pronounced and your mind interprets shadows or objects in the room as the thing that is there with you, or you may even feel as though you are being touched in some way, perhaps because the body begins very initial return to wakefulness state.
Now, I can tell you - though I am a rational, non-superstitious man - that waking up, being paralyzed, having the sense that something is near you, and then feeling that something put its arm around you induces fear.
It is a non-rational fear. It is an unlimited and uncontrolled fear. It is primeval and ingrained in us.
In each case, I was able to, with effort, begin to vocalize. Eventually sufficiently enough that my wife wakes up, and shakes me, and gets my body to get back into sync with my brain.
Immediately I am back to normal. I have no problem going right back to sleep, and I realize the scientific phenomenon that has occurred.
But... I can tell you that the fear for those seconds is the most terrifying thing you can possibly imagine.
The condition has been studied and is associated with Sudden arrhythmic death syndrome, where individuals have died in their sleep.
In the three times in my life that it has happened to me, if the fear had for some reason gone on for a longer period - I can understand how one might die from cardiac arrest.
I explain this because the story we read makes me think of that raging, uncontrollable, visceral fear and how the young man in the story felt.
Last edited: