What's new

My NYC barbershop straight razor shave experience

I've been a minor league shave geek for a year and a half now. Two safety razors, huge assortment of blades from a sampler, a dozen or so creams, half a dozen aftershaves at most. Still hard for me to get a superior shave, even when I use T&H preshave oil, T&H West Indian Limes, E Jagger brush and DE razor with 7 o'clock or feather blades followed by Skin Food as my "A Team". But still infinitely better than the multi-blade monstrosities.

So we went down to see the Yankees play Detroit, and beforehand I found Cambridge Chemists, where Scott P. told me I could go a block down to 62nd and Lexington, "Premium Barbershop".

Tiny place. Not the luxury high-end GS Trumper style place I'd had in mind, but not a dump either. Oh well. Sat back in the chair, and the barber (sorry, name escapes me, but a young guy) proceeds to massage some patchouli smelling stuff into my face. His first comment was "tough beard, ha?" So now at least I feel validated about how hard it is to get a good shave. I think part of the idea of massaging the stuff was to learn the grain patterns. Next hot towels and some shaving cream (Lucky Tiger lemon type stuff, I think) and more massaging into my face. Then he proceeds to shave, hot towel, reapply, shave, etc. for 50 full minutes. His solution for my cleft chin was to have me put my tongue in front of my lower front teeth all the way down to fill out the area. Also to fill my cheeks with some air. He stretched and scraped. No pain, really, but I could feel it.

After four hot towels and many passes and touch ups (he REALLY did it like an artist) he gave me a cold towel. He put some sort of balm on me, rubbed that in, and I finally could feel the finished product with my hands.

Fanfreakingtastic. My wife agreed it was like being ten years younger. Smooth as silk. Very nice, humble guy, and very reasonable price, not the 70-odd bucks I was expecting to pay.

I went back to Scott at Cambridge and talked to him awhile about the experience and to spend some money out of appreciation and to broaden my horizons. I appreciated the fact that his biggest advice was "use what you have before it dries out". But I wasn't leaving empty handed, so he recommended Castle Forbes' expensive cream (just a travel size for a trial) as the richest, most moisturizing cream available.

I've used it once since coming back, and it's also incredible. This is the real thing. I could've make enough lather for a week of shaves with a tiny bit on the brush. I now will order from him the next time I need to stock up.

Yanks lost, BTW. I'm a PHillies fan anyway...

cheers
 
Glad to hear you can still find a good shave in a barber shop! I've been looking around my hometown a bit but haven't found a place id like to try yet!
 
In walk past there every day on my way to work. Always intrigued me. Now I'll have to go in for a shave. Glad you had such a good experience.
 
Great story. Too bad you are a Phillies fan, though. If your team makes it all the way, my Yankees will be there waiting :biggrin:
 
I'm pretty sure it was a disposable straight blade. There was no stropping, like I remember from my childhood, when I went down the steps into the barbershop with dad, and Al the barber made that cool rhythmic sound with razor against strop. Tic-tica-tic-tica-tic, etc.
 
R

razorshavenyc

I had been going twice a month for straight razor shaves to various NYC shops, but then I found Barber's Blueprint at 181 Mulberry Street and I'm going weekly because they cost a lot less than the trendy places, they keep their appointment times, and they do a much better job than the tattoo covered trendoid barbers.

If you want a great straight razor shave experience go visit George and Arthur at Barber's Blueprint and tell them that Dan referred you. NYC Barber - Barber's Blueprint
 
I had been going twice a month for straight razor shaves to various NYC shops, but then I found Barber's Blueprint at 181 Mulberry Street and I'm going weekly because they cost a lot less than the trendy places, they keep their appointment times, and they do a much better job than the tattoo covered trendoid barbers.

If you want a great straight razor shave experience go visit George and Arthur at Barber's Blueprint and tell them that Dan referred you. NYC Barber - Barber's Blueprint

I went here and really didn't like it. The younger guy did my shave, did the first pass well with a disposable straight. But then he did his second pass with a fusion (no idea if it was new or clean for that matter). He scraped the fusion all over my face and I left with my left cheek as red as a beet. The preshave oil that he applied before the second pass was also very thick and greasy; felt very hard to wash off. I'm willing to try the premium barbershop though, can I ask how much it was? blueprint was around 20.
 
Paul Mole is at 74th and Lexington (I get my hair cut there). There are a few barber shops in the immediate area. Best haircuts I've ever gotten at Paul Mole, though. Highly recommended.

Ben
 
I went to a barber college for my first and only straight shave. I was disappointed. I chalked it up to the guy being a student. I've heard of only one other place in my town that does it so I'll have to go there next time I need a shave and a hair cut.

Cool story though. Whenever I think of NY and straight shaves I think of the scene in Rounders.
 
Top Bottom