MWF vs TOBS Cream

[BYUTexan]

If you could pick one, which one would you pick and why?

 

[Prince]

I love both, but I'd have to pick TOBS for the scents and the ease of lathering. MWF is great, but requires a bit more work to get lathered correctly.

 

[MoJoe]

I have never used MWF so can't give you a + or - on their product. I have heard very good things about it. On the other hand, I have two creams from TOBS, Eton College and Rose. I love the TOBS creams. They whip up to a thick, rich lather very quickly using very little cream. They're slick and deliver a terrific shave. And at about $14 per tub you get a quality English, 3-T cream at a very affordable price. No doubt that I'll be ordering more in the future. They're not my only creams but both are part of my rotation and I use each at least 1x per week. If you're looking for a cream and have settled on TOBS I would highly recommend it.

 

[Ru4scuba?]

I have both. TOBS cream IMHO.

MWF has "legions of fans" to quote Jim....and also "legions of detractors" IMHO. I'm one of the latter. Just doesn't lather efficiently and as quickly as TOBS. Plus, I like the scent 10X better!

 

[markb]

MWF. Why?

1. I'm a soap guy
2. It has tallow
3. It shaves better than any cream I've ever used

YMMV

 

[SilkySmooth]

It depends on a few variables

Soap vs Cream
Scent vs MWF
type of brush used
consideration of another soap (Tabac/L'Occitane Cade)

 

[marvin100]

mwf. Why?

1. i'm a soap guy
2. it has tallow
3. it shaves better than any cream i've ever used

ymmv

+1

 

[40_Caliber]

MWF

'nuff said

.40