Scents are so subjective that it is difficult to say which scents will appeal to an individual..
Barrister and Mann makes great soaps, but of the 9 soaps of various formulations in my den, I have not found any scents that rate 10/10 to my nose.
Grooming Department makes great soaps, but it is difficult to recommend scents as every release has a different scent profile. If you find a scent you really like, you better stock up while you can as it may never be released again.
The following group have both scents I like and scents I do not enjoy.
Ariana and Evans
Murphy and McNeil seems to have excellent scents, at least to my nose. I have 7 of them and love every one. I cannot say that for any other brand in my collection.