My experience is the same as @Teutonblade
Attempt 3 - another day and a half has passed and I tossed in another new lab blue and listened for the symphony...and crickets. Just kidding - the loudest angle was maybe a tick toward steep from where I perceive as neutral. I will say the comfort did increase, but by only a touch. Ultimately, I think this razor falls into a notch above what I want in aggression. While the cutting angle is very generous, I would say the optimal cutting angle is a little narrow for me. That being said - if I used the razor everyday, I am assuming it would become second nature. I've never had a razor that really increased drastically from where I originally thought it was after a shave or two and this is not an exception to that - Or maybe I just gave up on them too early . I just like mindless auto-pilot-like shaves and this is not that for me.
What I am thinking about doing is doing a wtg pass (or 2) with my overlander and then just try the ATG performance to see if this could be a niche razor for me. I've been known to use two razors before and not opposed to that if one excels ATG more than the other. Then it is back to its home!
Thanks @catchacoolbreeze and @Wgg2017 I'm looking forward to the Athena. It has a lot of fans and I appreciate the generous opportunity to try it out.Good luck to @Pineapple who is getting this next!
The Athena arrived today thank you again @catchacoolbreeze and @Wgg2017 . I swap blades on Saturday so the Athena got a fresh Rapira Swedish Super steel. I ended up using the Bayonetta handle, balances well and doesn't look too out of place.
To me the blade feel is pretty minimal but it is there, but the blade feels solid with no chatter so it felt really predictable during the shave.
During the first set of passes I did try different angles using the sound of the blade. Went from neutral to steep and steep does feel slightly scrapey. I did try only side of the neck neutral and the other side steep, I was able to feel more stubble on the steep side so stuck with the more comfortable neutral angle. I usually only do atg passes even under the nose which is usually a single buffing pass. The Athena made it easy with the small gap and exposure which makes it feel safe with a solid predictable blade feel. It was pretty efficient for me on the first shave. Skin felt smooth with no irritation post shave. I do think I need to try shallow and wanted to try another handle but the current Bayonetta felt great.
View attachment 1873876
First one that came to mind was the Ghost, the .90 is still mild similar to the Athena. The Merica and Winning V2 are also mild and good atg, Winning requires a a little pressure for me and it's angle is locked. The Merica was a favorite for a while but I think the SS version may have worked better for me but I've been only using the newer Ti which is lighter and has the newer baseplate. There's also a few vintage Gillettes that may fit in there but it's been a while since they were used. Favorites being the New improved Tuckaway, #58, and Aristocrat Jr. Last 2 being smooth like the Athena and way more efficient than the shave felt.After you get a couple more shaves in I’d be curious to know how it compares in terms of smoothness atg with other razors you’ve used.
Well has the boat sailed on trying before you buy?
If the Overlander works great for you stick with it and don’t look back. I don’t know why but I sometimes try razors that are too aggressive for me and every time the same whisker on my neck ends up becoming an ingrown. I really wish I could nuke that one whisker. If I’d just stick with what works for me I’d have no problems.
Regarding the Wild Whiskers you have, tried to pullThat stop the ingrown for a while, until it takes time to grow back?
I personally get once in a while what I call, Wild Whisker Hairs, one THICK & Black, and one Gray Fine growing out of exact spot on neck, or face. Easy to locate, by poking & touching with my Surgical Tweezers, the Thick Black Whiskers HURTS when touched, like someone stick me with straight pin. Again I poke, locating the THICK BLACK WHISKER, pulling it out. As soon as it is pulled, face or neck feel 110% better, and pain free.
If you want to try the Lambda Ares I have started a pass around for that razor. Equally outstanding and a bit more efficient.Yes, I’m afraid the opportunity to join this pass around has ended.