Is one better than the other? I know they are both good

[FrankD]

Ok so here's the deal i may be able to secure only one of these, (financial limitations): Vintage "WADE & BUTCHER" Cut Throat Straight Razor

Etched is 'SPECIAL..Wade and Butcher' Sheffield England. Or: a vintage Puma solingen. The question is, is one generally considered better than the other? Assume both are in reasonable condition.

 

[noahpictures]

Puma, if its in decent condition. It's more valuable. Both are great shavers.

 

[Captain Pre-Capsize]

The short answer is they are both equally valued in my opinion. There are other variables to consider however. Round nose or spike point; how hollow is each one; they are likely neither a wedge, is that important; what are the scales made of / what is their condition. I could go on...

 

[mdunn]

theyre all good makers. without more information, just go with the one in the best condition

 

[ladykate]

How wide are they? Generally, the Puma has the better resale value given other things being equal. Specifically, a 5/8 Puma will go for more than a 5/8 Wade and Butcher of the same general state of decomposition. If there is a difference in the looks, go with the better looking one.

 

[Giant Kiwi]

I have a W&B Special and a Puma.
I like the special a bit more than the puma mainly for the square point and it's shave sharp at the moment.

 

[Mike H]

Assuming condition is equal..., Puma.

But read this first. http://wiki.badgerandblade.com/What_to_look_for_when_buying_a_second_hand_straight_razor