How would you rank Cella, Tabac, and D.R. Harris?

[JCinPA]

All three are excellent and well-regarded around here. I'm settling in on owning (repurchasing) just these three soaps and I rank them this way

Cella
Tabac
D.R. Harris

I'm curious how people who use all three view them. I like them all, but in that specific order.

 

[Cobra0369]

The only one out of that group I have is Cella. Absolutely fantastic!

 

[nemo]

All three are great performers but I would push Cella down a notch or two only because I'm not fond of the scent (little red tub if it makes any difference).

 

[tiernan22]

I may get chastised for this one but Cella never worked out for me. It just didn't provide the same cushion nor slickness that I've become accustomed to. I guess this is a true example of YMMV. DR Harris is wonderful stuff, however.

 

[TallyShave]

I would go:

Tabac
Cella
DR Harris

All within the margin of error of each other though and all great soaps.

 

[AABCDS]

That's a tough one. I would rank them in the order of D.R. Harris, closely followed by Tabac, and Cella.

 

[lt114]

D.R. Harris
Tabac
Cella

I love all 3 of these soaps and if you ask me this question a month from now the order could be the exact opposite.

 

[jazzguy]

Cella set my face on fire. I won't buy Tabac. But I do have four different scents of Harris and backup pucks of a couple of the scents.

 

[inspiringK]

I have also found Cella to be a good performer, but not in my top 5 or even top 10 for performance. So, I would say DR Harris, Tabac..... Cella.

 

[shaverjoe]

I have only used Tabac, but it is a GREAT soap!

 

[shavefreak]

1.Tabac - I rate this above the others by an wide margin, fast lathering and far more protective

2. DR Harris - not good enough to be in my rotation - good but just misses better moisturizing than Cella
3. Cella - not good enough to be in my rotation - not an almond fan a lot of better soaps for me.

 

[Edinburgh]

D.R. Harris
Tabac
Cella

All love all 3 of these soaps and you ask me this question a month from now the order could be the exact opposite.

+1

 

[merkur59]

1. DR Harris
2. Cella
3. Tabac

For me, tabac is last because of its scent.

 

[shavefreak]

ha - yeah, I get that.... last in scent for sure

1. DR Harris
2. Cella
3. Tabac

For me, tabac is last because of its scent.

 

[njpaddy]

I no longer like or use soft soaps so it's

Harris
Tabac (despite being out of rotation for a year)
Cella

 

[FL shaver]

Cella
Tabac
Harris

Kept putting off getting the tub of Cella thinking it could not be as good as Tabac and another of my favorites MWF. I was wrong.

 

[bassopotamus]

Personally,

I am one of about 2 people on earth that just doesn't have good luck with Tabac. I tried and tried, and never got a decent shave out of it. I'm sure it is something I did wrong, as most people rave about it. I ended up giveing it to my brother.

cella and DR Harris are both fantastic. I don't know that I could rank, I like both

 

[Chris H]

All three are excellent and well-regarded around here. I'm settling in on owning (repurchasing) just these three soaps and I rank them this way

Cella
Tabac
D.R. Harris



I'm curious how people who use all three view them. I like them all, but in that specific order.

I would rank them in reverse order simply because I think performance is pretty even, but D.R. Harris scents are hands down far superior (IMHO) to Tabac or Cella.

 

[cooltide]

tabac by country mile
cella is only average
not used harris

 

[SfaX]

1 - tabac
2 - tabac
3 - tabac