Another aftershave similar to Skin Bracer is Gabel's Original, usually sold by barber supply stores for $6-8 per 16 oz bottle. You may need to add a little more menthol to get the same effect.
I've had good luck with all the Gabel's aftershave I've tried.
Thanks for the suggestions guys. I usually get a bottle every few years or so. Got the itch last November and all the stores I‘ve visited have been out since then. Was just wondering if others had noticed the same thing.