So after reading numerous post about Arko I decided to finally order a stick off Ebay for $3.29. Received it on Saturday and promptly opened the stick. My first impression on the scent was lemon pez candies, then soap, then soapy lemon pez. I understand the urine puck reference. I smashed it into a bowl and lathered it up. It was one of the easiest soaps I have ever lathered. Got thick yogurt lather fast. The scent to my nose changed at this point it went from a soapy lemon pez smell which I liked to more of a citronella smell. Similar to Williams but not so strong. The scent is like eating lemon pez candies while burning a citronella candle. The scent was not as strong as posts lead me to believe but it did linger for an hour or two after the shave. The shave was good cushion and slick. Overall I would say that this was a good soap, not great as I don't like citronella. I would recommend this soap to people new to wet shaving due to how easy it is to lather.