I'm glad this thread has resurfaced. I've been trying to learn more about the quality, and the fit of different styles and brands of boots recently, as well as where to find them. I currently have some Ariats with the square toe and walking heel, and a couple of pair of Justin ropers in deerskin and smooth ostrich. I was surprised that the Justins fit in the same size as my normal shoe size, when so many have said they need to go a 1/2 size or even a full size smaller in Justins, and my Ariats are a full size larger than my normal shoe size. The Ariats have been amazingly comfortable from the first time I put them on, but I haven't worn them very much yet, and am curious to see how they wear over time. For some perspective, the Ariats do have sort of a tennis shoe feel, rather than a regular leather shoe or boot feel, and the most comfortable boots or shoes I've ever worn were Florsheim Imperial oxford dress shoes, which of course are no longer available and what they make now doesn't come close. They molded to the shape of my feet after a few months and I could wear them all day and night and my feet never got tired of them.