Choosing between TOBS Colognes

[Obsessed Latherer]

I am looking for an everyday barbershop scent to wear. I do know about Mr Taylor and its uses in the winter time, but I am looking for a good year round scent which leads me to choose between Shaving Shop and Eton College. I have never tried these colognes but I do have the new parabens free Eton College shaving cream. Which one would you recommend?

 

[Obsessed Latherer]

I have read the descriptions on the Taylors website but they just seem to muddy the distinctions between its different colognes. Does anybody have experience with these?