Proraso Green vs Taylor's Peppermint 1/2-1/2 shave

[Doc Dan]

Using a DE razor both Proraso and TOBS are just acceptable. Neither stacks up for me with a straight razor. My favorite Italian is Cella Almond (red), which is a tallow soap. I haven't tried TOBS Peppermint, but I assume it is like their other offerings, performance wise. But, people are different and what works for one doesn't for another and that is why we have variety.

 

[Juanmosey]

I have used both Proraso Green and TOBS Peppermint extensively. IMHO, the TOBS Peppermint is superior to Proraso Green in every respect. The slickness, the ability to whip up a good lather, and the scent are all much better with TOBS Peppermint. I'll continue to use the rest of the Proraso Green that I have only because I hate to throw our product, but that will be the last of it.

I loved the peppermint but the coconut was not good.