I got their Gentlemen's Choice Soap Collection with 12 bath soaps. Working through it and enjoying it a lot. The soaps are well scented and last a long time. I thought the Almond was great, as was the Number 6. The Greenbriar was ok. Think I'm using the Jockey Club now, which is fine, but not my favorite. Of course ymmv.
I have their Presidential sampler (#6, Almond Cold Cream and Jockey Club). I haven't broken them out but am interested in how they perform.
Cost for C-M is a sticking point for me, as it works out to just a shade under $1.50/ounce. Compared to Pre de Provence, which is 88 cents per ounce for the 250g bars, I don't see how C-M is going to wow me that much.
For comparison's sake, a 6-pack of Dial bars at Walgreens works out to less than 30 cents an ounce.
Tried their lime, which barely smells like lime but has a very clean scent. The bar was 8 bucks, has lasted for 3 months at least, and didn't dry me out at all in winter. I think for 8 bucks it was a steal, getting cheaper is only better!
I really like their Sandalwood and would like to get Tricorn, but I stockpiled when I found them at TJ Maxx, which I think was quite a bit less than online even with the sale.