I know that there are many fans of C.O. Bigelow's Bay Rum. It seems to go in and out of production--the last I heard at the Bigelow store in PA (before it closed) was that Bay Rum was gone. Apparently it isn't. Bigelow's webpage shows the EdT, AS Balm and bodywash as all available.
http://www.bigelowchemists.com/c-o-bigelow-products/men-s.html?p=1
http://www.bigelowchemists.com/c-o-bigelow-products/men-s.html?p=1