Best Tobacco Scented Aftershaves?

[Whisky&Steak]

Hello Everyone,
I am currently searching for new Aftershaves to try, and decided to aim for something tobacco scented. Unfortunately I am having trouble doing so (I purchased Wholly Saw Merchant of Tobacco before reading reviews from different sites and soon realized it smells of chocolate rather than tobacco) and would greatly appreciate input from the B&B community. Personally I'd love a strong, smoky scent, but as I know nothing about this area of scents I'm open to suggestions.

In addition to your help, what's your favourite tobacco scented aftershave?

Thank you,
W&S

 

[Matt O]

Yes! I think Merchant of Tobacco smells more like a chocolate stout! I like it, but it was not the scent profile I was looking for when I purchased it.

I really like RazoRock Puros, and Santa Maria Novella!

You will like enjoy both of them!

Vr

Matt

 

[OkieStubble]

Bootlegger's Perfecto Virginia and Perfecto Maduro.

 

[Matt O]

I never heard of Bootleggers! I will have to check it out!

Vr

Matt

 

[guitarslinger]

There are just so many interpretations of what "Tobacco" smells like. Here are a few I have that smell like somebody "smoking"

Razorock Puros is a tad sweet and spicy, but very reminiscent of smoking cigars.

Barrister and Mann Leviathan is not sweet at all. Smells a lot like smoking cigars.

Tcheon Fung Sing Linea Intenso Tabacum Crepito smells like a cigar lounge, but with a very sweet toasted marshmellow scent

Tobacco flower and green tobacco aftershaves smell nothing like "tobacco" to me, fwiw.

 

[Ad Astra]

I never heard of Bootleggers! I will have to check it out!

Vr

Matt

Matt; "Bootlegger's" is a house brand, if you will: a blend made by forum members. Search those names here for more ...

Bootleggers 7 Parts Series

AA

 

[Bakker1964]

Henri et Victoria's Cognac and Cuban Cigar.

 

[shavefan]

Boellis Panama 1924

 

[bmw45mo]

Jeeves of Hudson Street, Tobacco Bay Leaf
WSP, Tobacco

 

[sarimento1]

 

[RhoCurly]

Pinaud Whiskey Woods. Despite the name this aftershave is primarily a pipe tobacco scent. From the label: “combines tobacco leaf and bergamot with whiskey and woods to finish each shave on a smooth smoky note”. One of my favorites for fall and winter.

 

[bray144k]

No votes for Chiseled Face Sherlock? I've never tried it, but it seems to have quite the following here.

 

[kwickone]

WSP Tobacco is rock solid.

 

[Whisky&Steak]

Pinaud Whiskey Woods. Despite the name this aftershave is primarily a pipe tobacco scent. From the label: “combines tobacco leaf and bergamot with whiskey and woods to finish each shave on a smooth smoky note”. One of my favorites for fall and winter.

My current barber has some on hand right now, I'll see if I can try it this week.

 

[ask4Edge]

SMN TT

 

[NCGent]

Pinaud Whiskey Woods. Despite the name this aftershave is primarily a pipe tobacco scent. From the label: “combines tobacco leaf and bergamot with whiskey and woods to finish each shave on a smooth smoky note”. One of my favorites for fall and winter.

+1 I really like this stuff quite a bit

 

[FuzzFace513]

yup Whiskey Woods is my all time favorite

 

[pbrmhl]

To my nose, PAA Cavendish is the classic. I smoked a pipe for years, and Cavendish smells just like buying a new tin of Cavendish pipe tobacco, unscrewing the tin lid, folding back the accordion paper, and taking a big sniff. Cavendish was not my favorite tobacco, but boy howdy did PAA nail the scent...

 

[Charlie R]

Alt Innsbruck is a nice tobacco aftershave

 

[boilerphan]

Hemingway Accoutrements aftershave tonic is fantastic.