What's new

At long last, something my wife likes!

I should preface this by saying that my wife has been averse to cologne and similar scents for years, and it seems that synthetic fragrances particularly give her problems. It hasn't been an issue for most of the 31 years we've been married as I've had allergies/sensitivities/hayfever type inconveniences, and didn't use them either. But now that I started taking Allegra not only am I more tolerant of unavoidable environmental airbornes, I can finally enjoy scents again. I only started a couple of months ago but I have always had a sensitive nose (perhaps part of the original problem), and I have greatly enjoyed lately not needing to avoid fresh flowers, new-mown grass, etc. or personal scent products. So, I've been trying samples of this and that about as fast as I can get at them.

And I hit an impasse right off. My wife simply could not tolerate any of the things that smelled good to me. Tabac bugged her so badly that I tossed the whole bottle in front of her to assure her that it was gone (a mistake, but before I found this place where I could have found it a new owner). Try as I might, though, and especially seeking scents that should be light and short lived, they all bothered her. I suppose I've been scent-starved so long that I liked nearly all of them a little, and it was frustrating that we could find no common ground. But I love her (insert Ron White snigger here).

Tonight after a shower I picked up my tiny sample vial of Trumper's Skye and instead of just touching the little dabber to my cheek as I've been doing, I went for broke and poured the whole thing into a palm and smeared it on my cheeks and neck. I'd done a really bad job of shaving with a fresh Red Personna and the Fatboy cranked up to 11 and skint myself a bit, and didn't want to use both an A/S and scent. I figured that she'd complain but after a long hot day of cutting brush and fighting sun (I'm scorched) and gnats I was in a less than considerate mood. The neighbors all have dogs and cats that very considerately don't foul their own yards, and after wading into hidden messes with a high-speed big-string weedeater all day long, I wanted to smell something nice and smell it loud. I was a bit disappointed that after applying the Skye I squinted to find it was an EdT, I was hoping for something more in the Hai Karate strength as long as it smelled like something other that Gravy Train or Tuna Casserole, run once through the beast.

And ... she loved it. The Skye, that is. She came over to give me hug after my shower and said "Wow, you smell great!". This is a milestone for us, considering that we have both been stymied when it comes to EdT's etc., in fact I warned her that I was "stinky". The odd thing is that I just grabbed it from the samples, it would never have been my first choice (of course, I'm a Lime fanatic, which is good because it's one of the few things that hasn't set her nose to dripping).

Just gibbering because I finally see some daylight in one of the simple pleasures of life I'd long forgone and nearly forgotten, but also as a reminder that despite the fact that all of us here know it, it's far too easy to forget just how drastically that our individual body chemistry affects scent products when applied. I've always been an outdoorsy type both by trade and/or recreation and gravitated toward no scent or the "woodsy" type things, and never considered one of the lighter more cosmopolitan scents like I perceive Skye to be - nor had she.

Now maybe she'll buy me some sex-ay designer jeans and a $200 french-cuff shirt so I can "pop" the collar and pretend I own no cufflinks. (nyuck, nyuck, look, I'm a TV vampire!).

Well, anyway, it was a real-world refresher in how assumptions come back to you, at least this time the revisit was pleasant.
 
That's an eye-opener. Go for it, dude. If you can tolerate rose-water and all other stinky stuff, you'll go far. YMMV, for sure.

I'm glad you and the missus have something in common.:thumbup1:
 
Oh, it gets worse - I got 2 samplers of Trumper's Skin Food and a couple of days ago when I did a similarly poor version of getting reaccustomed to a straight razor, I grabbed one on of the samples and dapped my beleagered cheeks and neck. I thought "wow, I need to buy some of this, that felt great" and all evening watching TV I kept thinking "what is that scent, I really like that". As I've said in earlier posts, long ago I developed animal attractants for use and sale and I have a working albeit rusty knowledge of a fairly wide range of natural scent ingredients, and I simply couldn't identify that particular scent. Subtle, but lingering, strangely pleasant, and I was surprised that I didn't recognize it as those are the perfect qualities for the animal attractant scents I once made and sold. I just couldn't believe that I couldn't recognize it, and guessed it was a clever combination of scents that my hominid nose just couldn't puzzle out as individual components the way a canine could.

Next morning I could still faintly smell it - again, ideal quality to me - and I went to where I shave and picked up the bottle and it said "Coral". Put on my reading glasses and found out the primary scent was ... rosewater! (see, I took the long way around but I got back to your post). Knock me down with a feather, but not for why you might think - roses are the one allergen that the desensitizing injections (allergy shots) which I took for extended periods at three times in my life cannot address. Maybe they can now, but then, if you were allergic to roses you walked upwind when you saw them if you had that sensitivity. It makes sense, in a way, we never had roses around the house, I always avoided them ... I lived to be 57 and didn't really know how a rose smelled! Now, I see why people like them and put up with the thorns and the difficulty of raising them despite the many pests and plant diseases that attack them.

You know, even if I were Yoda I'm not going to live long enough to learn the things I've missed along the way. I'm going to keep trying, though.
 
Last edited:
That's an eye-opener. Go for it, dude. If you can tolerate rose-water and all other stinky stuff, you'll go far.


I like the rose water. I really really like it (shades of Sally Fields). I'm doubting my lovly wife will feel likewise though. I could perhaps spring it upon her, though, and maybe she'll accept it. I should probably precede it with an unexpected encounter with a snake, which encounter I should have no obvious part. As Nixon said, it would be wrong, but we could do it. Women love a hero no matter how he smells, at least as a limited offer.

We have a family story of an uncle who didn't like turkey dressing and didn't want any of it put onto his plate. So one Thanksgiving, or maybe Christmas, someone put some on his plate as it was passed (probably my Aunt Betty Ann, who didn't give a crap what you wanted because in her mind then and now (age 88), nobody was that damned special(although she wouldn't have said "damned" now or then, but it was in her tone of voice)" and she said nothing about it. When Grace had been spoken and he took a bite he said, all too loudly, "This is great!!! What is it?" Someone told him is was dressing, and reminded him that he didn't like it. "BUT!" he said "YOU NEVER GAVE ME ANY OF IT BEFORE, HOW COULD I HAVE KNOWN? !!!" I think that rosewater was introduced as a masculine scent under just some circumstance. Or, maybe the snake thing. Obviously, someone was successful, and history is mute.

To paraphrase Robert Burns, "People are funnier than just about anybody".
 
It sounds like your allegies are to real roses, and most of the rose notes in fragrance are I'm quite sure, generally based on synthetics.

I love the Coral Skin Food. Just FYI, the also make it in Sandalwood and Lime.
It's the best thing I've found for my face after a good shave.

But to me, that scent is very fleeting. I'm amazed you could smell it much after the initial application. You must have a good nose.
 
And be a bit careful. IMHO rose water and Coral do not smell alike to me. Coral has much more of a bit deeper rose scent. Rose water (hydro-something from QED that I have) smells watery. Make sure you try real rose water first.
 
In case it helps--and I have no idea what Coal Skin Food may say on the side of the bottle, although it does seem darker and deeper than the rosewaters I know--Bulgarian rose, Turkish rose, Damascus rose, and rose otto are likely to signal that the rose product is deeper and richer smelling. Less floral, if that makes any sense at all. English or tea rose or say something like Elisabethan rose, anything with an English reference, is likely to be lighter and brighter, and to me potentially more girly. Coral may actually be a bit in between.

Also, most rose scents are a blend of things that include much that is not from a rose at all, even where they are "natural." For instance, I am sure there are natural rose scents that have nothing in them but geranium. Perhaps that will affect allergy issues!
 
My novel reading time is being devoted to classics that I, for some reason, have never read. :tongue_sm

What product does your wife finally approve of?
 
My novel reading time is being devoted to classics that I, for some reason, have never read. :tongue_sm

What product does your wife finally approve of?

He said Trumper's Skye.



He went on to say that he likes Coral Skin Food, too, but he's not sure his wife will enjoy it.
 
I was a math/science kid in school - hated english (where most of us read the classics I assume), absolutely hated it. Reading Of mice and men now.

Spoilsport, I thought you were being wry and biting and I was returning the favor.

The list of classics I haven't read is only slightly shorter that the full set of classics, read or not. I was steered toward math and science (little talent for it) and away from literature. When I find quiet time, I try to make amends.

I had to force myself to read Oscar Wilde as it was a blank space for me, but that experience caused me to become interested in other literature of the period and thus become acquainted with Saki/HH Munro. It was worth wading through Wilde to get to Saki, if you like dry wit and clever mischief.

My wife loves Steinbeck and has reminded me of that so much I avoid it as if he were Jade East, The Concentrated Essence. I'll probably like him if/when I relent.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Steinbeck kept a couple of bottles of Pinaud around. Nothing like a splash of Lilac Vegetal to freshen up things when you're sailing the Sea of Cortez.
 
I love rose water, but my wife thinks I smell like her grandmother.

:glare:

My wife wears Shalimar. My grandmother did as well. Hmm....coincidence?
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Steinbeck kept a couple of bottles of Pinaud around. Nothing like a splash of Lilac Vegetal to freshen up things when you're sailing the Sea of Cortez.

That's an awesome image. I've wondered what Steinbeck wore as he is one of my favorite writers.
 
Well, I'd be remiss if I didn't update this.

I bought a bottle of Skye, then I saw a good price on eBay for the cologne (damn that "things you might like" routine of theirs!). Of course, I bought it before the first bottle arrived.

So, I put more than just the tiny wipe off the sample-stopper stick of Skye I'd used when "Momma liked" on my neck. Not slathered, maybe 3 drops. I smelled it all night long (I shower and shave at night, and turn in late), in fact I started to think that it was the scent that was waking me up. By dawn I was sick of it. So, I waited several days, and tried it again with only two carefully metered droplets of the EdT. Even after the drydown, it's just overwhelmingly bad for either my chemistry, my nose, or both. In fact, after about an hour I decided to take a second shower and could still smell it slightly. It's just not for me. I dare not try the cologne. Too bad, because as I sad, Momma likes it a lot.

When I can round up some proper packing I think I'll put the pair up on the B/S/T forum at an attractive price, and find myself something that agrees with me better. I may not ask her opinion this time. :biggrin1:
 
Trumpers says that Skye smells like rosemary, the "leafy-rose aroma of geranium bourbon" with "bewitching top notes of floral-jasmine Ylang Ylang ... amidst the sensual notes of musk."

When I think of the Isle of Skye I think of the smell of turf smoke, salmon, seaweed and sea ether. Just sayin'...
 
Top Bottom