I tried my hand at making my own balm once again. This time I mixed about 2/3 generic witch hazel and about 1/6 each of generic aloe vera gel and glycerin. Then to help with the smell of the witch hazel I added several drops of lime essential oil. I have not idea if these proportions make sense or not as this is only my second batch. But the end result is a nice, smooth balm goes on easily, makes the face feel great after a shave and helps the skin, and smells nice to boot. I'm sure this can be improved, but I'm liking it pretty well right now.