While I have never smelled Polo Sport, I would believe this to be true. Upon smelling a sample of T&H Freshman, I was immediately reminded of Cool Water.
As for Pinaud Clubman, I love the stuff! In my opinion, it has incredible staying power for a fragrance priced at $5.99 for a 12-ounce bottle. I have personally found the fragrance mild enough to apply liberally after a shower (when skin is still wet), although I can't recommend doing so this time of year. If you're anything like me, your skin is dying of thirst with this cold, dry weather. I'm thinking the high alcohol content of Pinaud Clubman would only further dry out my skin.
