I own 400+ soaps. It is difficult to impress me. no unique scents but nice all around also a nice shave. I used their "Goon Grease" soap and their "barbershop" is similar to Stirling barbershop. I dont like either barbershop scent. Most Chiseled Face and Fine A. scents are my classic barbershop scents. If you collect tubs for artwork then get all the Larkharts.
Neither of these "barbershop" scents smell anything like barbershop to me. What does smell like barbershop are Fine A. soaps/splashes, Chiseled Face soap/splashes and especially Clubman Pinaud aftershaves.