What do you folks think of Vi-John shaving cream? It is inexpensive, for certain, at around 0.75 ¢ per tube.
What about Vi-John shaving cream?
- Thread starter Doc Dan
- Start date
I used to use it somewhat frequently. It's not bad, but personally, I think Palmolive classic is better and a better buy. But I was paying a few dollars for the Vi-John when it was on sale. Of the other creams I've tried, I'd say Proraso Green, Cyril R Salter, Geo F Trumper, and Taylor of Old Bond Street are all superior in performance.
Where can you find it for 75 cents? At that price it's certainly worth a try.
Where can you find it for 75 cents? At that price it's certainly worth a try.
It's as good as Arko and Derby creams, I enjoy the menthol version .
I hear it's very good but unfortunately no bargain on Ebay.
- Thread starter
- #5
It depends on where you live. Here, it is really cheap, and it is in in India, too.
They're pretty decent and does what it was made to do. It contains tea tree oil, which is definitely good. I have the Musk, Tropical Lime, Fruit Fusion, Classic as well as Icy Mint versions. I don't quite like the scent of the lime version. Classic and Icy Mint are really nice and I recommend them.
Overall, they perform pretty well for me and since its like only USD.50 a tube here in Malaysia, it's a bargain. They're always part of my rotation.
Overall, they perform pretty well for me and since its like only USD.50 a tube here in Malaysia, it's a bargain. They're always part of my rotation.
Is the mint version better than Godrej Menthol Mist?
I would say that the performance of both are quite similar but the Godrej feels a lot cooler on the face. Godrej definitely has more menthol in their cream. Godrej has lanolin which is great and Vi-John creams contain tea tree oil which is also pretty good. Both have completely different scents and both are pretty good in terms of performance.
- Thread starter
- #9
Godrej is one I've not heard of. It is very cheap in price. It is as good as old standbys like Arko and La Toja?
Godrej has been around for ages. They're very good indeed. There's the Fresh Lime, Menthol Mint and the regular Rich Foam varieties. I don't quite like the Fresh Lime scent though. All 3 performs very well. Pretty similar in terms of performance to the Arko shaving creams. Arko soaps are definitely a lot slicker.
I also feel that La Toja creams are a little slicker.
I definitely recommend trying Godrej if you can get them at a reasonable price.
I have only used the Icy Mint.
I believe it to be a great shave for a superb price. What a value cream.
I believe it to be a great shave for a superb price. What a value cream.
- Thread starter
- #13
Let us know what you think. That stuff is very cheap. I can get it for .79¢ a tube. Godrej, too.
It’s fairly decent with the injector razors I use. The lather has medium-densixty and its not too foamy.
I like soaps better for slickness, but this Vi-Jhon tube works well in the hard-water areas I live in
I like soaps better for slickness, but this Vi-Jhon tube works well in the hard-water areas I live in
Vi John is really slick. Right there with Palmolive and Karo in my favorite creams. It’s really pricy to get shipped over here in the states. I wish it was more affordable.
I don’t know what to think about Vi John. The menthol version hardly has any cooling effect and the skincare is not too good. The original version is pretty good but I have a couple of Indian creams besides Godrej with are much better - at least to me. 
Rick
Rick
- Thread starter
- #17
Which are better?I don’t know what to think about Vi John. The menthol version hardly has any cooling effect and the skincare is not too good. The original version is pretty good but I have a couple of Indian creams besides Godrej with are much better - at least to me.
Rick
I got a tube of the mint and used it the other day with my straight razor. I was surprised at the performance from a cream that is so inexpensive (79¢ per tube). It had good slickness to the lather, but the cushion was only so-so. It did have enough residual slickness that I could touch up some areas without re-lathering if I were really careful. This cream is not in the same league as La Toja, but for the money not too bad. I doubt I'll ever buy more, but I didn't throw it away, either.
- Thread starter
- #19
Yes, I had a nice, pleasant cooling, but not too much.
Sometimes menthol isnt among the Ingredients list. Icy Mint is the new menthol.
