Your vote for the worst soap ever tried

[mintong]

Aubrey Organics had a Bay rum shaving soap. It was so bad I never tried another of their products.

 

[5savages]

Aubrey Organics had a Bay rum shaving soap. It was so bad I never tried another of their products.

Their aftershave is actually pretty good. I bought it because of the witch hazel content and I've been happy with it.

 

[Dennis324]

Caswell Massey 1752.

Nicely packaged, triple milled, good reviews at Amazon and if your a newbie like I was, you jump all over it.

Worst soap I ever tried. Could not get a decent lather out of it no matter how hard I tried.

 

[STJ529]

Lightfoot Pine. It's a shame that it doesn't perform well because the scent is awesome.

 

[FL shaver]

Lightfoot Pine. It's a shame that it doesn't perform well because the scent is awesome.

When I pull this one out from under the sink, it will be combined with AOS Unscented cream. Might be 2020, but it will be used solely for its scent.

 

[IA_Cabby]

the new green proraso

 

[dfigz]

Erasmic no tallow stick

+1

 

[SEnSE]

the new green proraso

Really? I've read that most people find the new formulation to be very similar, if not better.

 

[Mad Man]

the new green proraso

I understand YMMV but.......what the puck??

 

[inspiringK]

I understand YMMV but.......what the puck??

Since we are taking a brief intermission to reflect on some of the entries.

I'll give a nod to Wilkinsons blue bowl.
I think it scarred my lathering technique.
The only thing I use it for now is to clean a brush - either of old soap deposits or new-animal-fur-stink.

The most awful soap I have had the misfortune to use. I cannot remember what made me buy it.

Really? I know it only smells like soap and nothing else and can be a bit drying, but I shaved with the blue bowl Wilkinson soap this morning and got a great shave. I have turned down many soaps and creams in the past, but this one is a solid performer. Maybe it is just easier to bash the cheaper mainstream products

 

[leonidas]

........Burt's Bees Shaving Cream

 

[oversaturn]

Erasmic shaving stick (veggie version). Simply useless - not even able to break in boar brushes.

But my biggest disappointment was the last version of the T&H Luxury soap. Pure crap. It created that "magic" lather - the one that disappears in just a few seconds.

 

[beginish]

Cade. That is all.

 

[packersfan117]

Conk was pretty awful, but Williams is the top of the trash heap (although it still beats canned goop). If I wanted to smell like citronella, I'd put Off on...or is it put on Off?

 

[IA_Cabby]

I understand YMMV but.......what the puck??

I don't know either? I'm seriously about to toss it in the trash. It has never lathered decently for me once. Heck, VDH Luxury lathers better.

 

[Doctor Love]

Without a doubt for me it's Coates Tea Tree & Rosemary. It just plain SUCKS! I couldn't throw it in the trash fast enough.

 

[JaggerDragger]

I don't know either? I'm seriously about to toss it in the trash. It has never lathered decently for me once. Heck, VDH Luxury lathers better.

Dont trash it, PIF it!

 

[Viseguy]

Arko stick. It may be is a good great soap, but and the scent is horrible. fantastic!

Fixed that for ya.

 

[rbaloha]

None. Any poor lather performer is easily corrected with added cream. Kiss My Face is a great uberlatherer.

 

[Uncle Brian]

I got a small puck of soap from a tobacconist it smelled like coconuts and was made in Australia.

Just plain no good at anything.